A Romney/Rice Ticket?

Now that Mitt Romney has become the presumptive Republican nominee for President, thoughts are turning towards his Vice Presidential pick.   The best choice he could make would be Condoleezza Rice.

First, a personal admission.  I support President Obama in his re-election bid.  But if his opposition were Romney-Rice, I’d take an Obama loss without too much dismay.    Though Romney seems to have sold his soul to the right wing to get the nomination, most of his history shows him as a moderate.   Rice is a foreign policy realist who helped craft the policy shift in 2006 that turned Iraq from an unmitigated disaster into a non-issue.   The US didn’t achieve its goals, but we were able to get out — a Nixonian “peace with honor” (which had been crafted by another realist-academic, Henry Kissinger).

Rice has the temperment, knowledge and background to be ready for the Presidency on day one.   If Romney loses, this could catapult her to the top of the 2016 list of GOP possibilities.   Unlike the current crop of uninspiring ideologues, Rice could reflect a Republican party more open, diverse, and pragmatic than before.   While the right wing of the GOP makes waves, the nominations of both McCain and Romney show that the centrists still dominate at the polls.

In 2012 a black woman as VP candidate would likely diffuse a lot of the negatives around Romney concerning gender and race.   Yet given her background it would not be seen as a cynical attempt at a overtly political game changer.    That was what McCain did when he picked Palin and it exploded in his face.   Rice would be a safe pick, nobody would doubt her intelligence and qualifications.

Team Obama has been riding the wave of improving poll numbers, a slowly improving economy and an opponent with high unfavorable ratings.    The Democratic base is becoming more enthused, the GOP base is wary.   Choosing Rice could inject real vitality into the Romney campaign.   It would also signal to independents that he’s not beholden to the right wing of the GOP and will be focused on governing pragmatically.   That could be enough to convince a lot of independents currently turned off by the ideologically charged GOP primary season to move to Romney.

To me the choice seems obvious — if Rice wants the slot, she should be offered it.   As speculation grows Rice is saying no — she does not want to be Vice President.    That was also the position Joe Biden took four years ago.   Does she mean it, or could Romney persuade her to run?   I suspect he could persuade her — few potential VPs say that they want the job before it’s offered.

Often the Vice President makes little difference in the race, and if Romney goes for the so called “vanilla” candidates like Daniels or McDonnell it probably won’t matter.    Romney is unlikely to make a catastrophic choice like McCain did four years ago, but could really benefit his campaign by choosing Rice.   This is Romney’s first “Presidential” decision.    Let’s see how he does.

  1. #1 by Ron Byrnes on April 20, 2012 - 16:54

    Interesting analysis Scott. Makes me wonder if 1) geography and the electoral college, 2) gender, or 3) ethnicity are the key variables in choosing a veep, or a fourth, ego. Many R’s and independents may prefer a Rice/Romney ticket. Begs the question, is he secure enough to pick someone as ready as himself to be president from day one?

    I wouldn’t mind Rice either for a far less intellectual and more self serving reason–I made a prediction a few years ago that we’ll never see another presidential race with four white males. Of course with Obama seeking a second term, I was already in the clear this go round.

    • #2 by joeyslaptop on April 29, 2012 - 05:19

      I don’t think this would pull black or white women voters to either side. It would, however, completely nullify the potential race and gender card in this presidential race: Obama/Biden -vs- Romney/Rice.

  2. #3 by pino on April 23, 2012 - 00:37

    Now that Mitt Romney has become the presumptive Republican nominee for President, thoughts are turning towards his Vice Presidential pick.

    I agree with the analysis on this one.

    Romney is a rich white man. I think he would be making a mistake to pick another rich white man.

    I don’t like Rubio or Paul Ryan for the same reason I didn’t like Obama [and McCain ] in that they both haven’t been in charge of anything. They just vote.

    Condi is a good pick, as is Nikki Haley.

    • #4 by Scott Erb on April 23, 2012 - 00:47

      Yes, I think Nikki Haley would a good pick. I recall Rice gave a powerful speech at the GOP convention (I believe in 2004) and she’s got a very distinguished foreign policy record. I don’t know Haley very well.

  3. #5 by brucetheeconomist on April 23, 2012 - 00:52

    I’d like this! Given Obama’s populist rhetoric: it might even bring me back to the GOP.

    My feeling is Romney won’t make such a good choice. I think Rob Portmanteau to win Ohio.

    Also I think Rice is a good choice but to associated with the Bush 2 administration.

  4. #6 by Alan Scott on April 23, 2012 - 14:45

    Not that Rice is a bad choice, but agreeing with Bruce she is too associated with Bush and the far lefties just will never forgive her for that . Plus Condi has always indicated that she has no interest in returning to the Washington pressure cooker .

    Romney has a good case of economic competence to make . He turned around the winter Olympics in 02, so it’s not as if he is as inexperienced as Obama. Rubio and Ryan are good for balancing Romney’s main weak point, which is a pliability of principle . They however are too valuable where they are. Haley is too new yet and would be cut to pieces in the campaign meat grinder .

    I don’t think he would do it, but Mitch Daniels is the perfect guy . He has a record, is competent to take over in a pinch, and I would pay to see him debate Joe Biden .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: