A Greek Tragedy

All eyes are on Greece as the fate of Europe’s economy and the European common currency is on the line.    The IMF and G20 states have pledged to prevent an economic collapse in Europe which would, undoubtedly, have severe ramifications for the US.   As one German friend of mine joked “Greece, the cradle and the grave of western civilization.”

The plan looks good on paper.  Greece borrowed an unsustainable amount of money and now must cut spending and raise its taxes to balance the budget.   Meanwhile the EU and IMF will intervene to both help stabilize Greek’s finances and recapitalize banks that may be vulnerable to Greek default.    It should work, in theory.

In practice, though, things are messy.   One problem is Greek domestic politics.  Angered by the corruption and political incompetence that brought them to this point, the Greeks are engaged in a two day general strike that has essentially shut down the country.   125,000 protesters in Athens, Thessaloniki, Patras and Heraklion showed anger at the government and its austerity plan.   People’s incomes are declining in real terms, and the mix of spending cuts and tax increases make the recession even worse.     Calling the cuts “unfair, anti-social and inefficient” they demand the country reject the austerity proposals.  3000 police classed with 70,000 protesters in Athens, mostly peacefully but not always.

The Greek government is in bind.   They need to cut debt; their debt load is unsustainable.   The bond markets still show a 24% interest rate on Greek bonds, meaning that any more debt would be extremely costly, and would drive up bond yields further.   Greece cannot simply go along as it has been.   Moreover, austerity is the price the EU is demanding to help them avoid default and stay in the Eurozone.

The Greek government is thus implementing the austerity measures out of necessity.    However, they could decide not to, and simply accept default.      If Greece defaulted, the pain would shift to the banks of Europe which could fail unless recapitalized with government funds.   The danger would be that the Greek default could lead to a dumping of Spanish, Italian, Portugese and Irish bonds, creating a crisis far greater than the Greek default.  As I noted awhile back, contagion is the real danger.

To be sure, a Greek default would make it a bit easier for the country to dig itself out of its hole.  There would still need to be spending cuts and tax increases to get a balanced budget, but they wouldn’t have the burden of so much debt to repay on top of that.  That is the path favored by many protesters in Greece; bankruptcy is welcome if debt is weighing you down.    Any default, however, almost ensures contagion.     It might help the Greeks, but ignite a global crisis.

To try to minimize the risk of contagion, a Greek default would probably be coupled with a removal of Greece from the Eurozone.   Letting a country default while maintaining the Euro as its currency is something that the Europeans cannot allow.   If Greece leaves the Eurozone, the result would be inflation and devaluation of the Drachma.   Since new Greek bonds would have very high interest rates (especially given the certainty of inflation), Greece would find borrowing money nearly impossible, and still would have to institute austerity programs.   That would push Greece back into crisis, and serve as an example to others the potential cost of leaving the Eurozone.

The EU could then try to prevent contagion by making it clear that defaults by other states are not likely given the cost it would entail to have them leave the zone.     Seeing what happens when set adrift from the Euro, governments in countries at risk would be more motivated than ever to engage in austerity politics.   After all, those in power listen to the moneyed elite more than the people on the street.

For Greece the devalued drachma would lead to increased trade competitiveness and lure in tourism.   Over years they’d stabilize the economy and potentially be able to rejoin the Eurozone in a decade or two.   No doubt the EU would by that time enforce the criteria strictly — Greece never should have been allowed to join in 2001.  Greece could not leave the Eurozone without defaulting.   Otherwise the depreciating drachma would mean that Euro denominated debt would grow dramatically simply do to changing exchange rates.   So leaving the Eurozone must be coupled with default.

For the EU the dilemma now is whether they should continue trying to save Greece, or focus instead on recapitalizing the banks and defending against contagion.   They have already spent so much money to stabilize Greece that switching tactics would be seen as an admission they got it wrong on the tax payers dime.   That money would have simply been thrown into a pit, bringing nothing of value.

That leads them to want to see this through to the end.   Yet it’s like getting your car repaired over and over — at some point you have to eat the loses and just buy a new one, realizing you should have done so at the time of the first repair.   If Greek protests grow and the government becomes unstable, default may be inevitable.   In that case it would again need to be coupled with leaving the Eurozone to avoid contagion.

Watching this play itself out is fascinating, even though I think most people are oblivious to the implications this drama has for the rest of the world.     Where once the fate of Europe was decided in war rooms by generals with maps spread out tracking troop movements and supply lines, now it’s in board rooms with business and political leaders looking  at spread sheets and bond yields.

  1. #1 by Sean Patrick Hazlett on October 19, 2011 - 17:59

    Excellent analysis, Scott.

    These are very scary times, indeed.

  2. #2 by Black Flag® on October 19, 2011 - 20:47

    Told ya this would happen, but ya didn’t believe me….

    • #3 by Scott Erb on October 19, 2011 - 20:51

      Everybody knew there would be massive protests in Greece. Nothing here is surprising to me, or unexpected. This is just a continuation of my analysis from last week.

  3. #4 by modestypress on October 19, 2011 - 22:10

    In the United States, the conflict between conservatives/tea party adherents seems to be driving us toward a new “civil war,” though the geographical implications of “red state” vs. “blue state” conflicts or secession are confusing and frightening. Europe never really had enough traction to become a true “United States of Europe” and the problems of different cultures and languages trying to merge into one compatible political/economic marriage are formiddable and terrifying.

    We are all doomed, unless we will be saved, perhaps by friendly aliens from outers space or the Second Coming of Jesus.

  4. #5 by modestypress on October 19, 2011 - 22:11

    I am dyslexic and getting old. I meant to say conflict between…and liberals/Occupy Wall Street adherents.

  5. #6 by Alan Scott on October 20, 2011 - 00:48


    I thought my eyes had become untrustworthy. This whole scene was put in motion years ago by the EU at any price idea. Greece was somehow allowed in and allowed live beyond it’s means by borrowing at rates that were meant for France and Germany . The Europeans built a model that could not last. The victims are the Greek citizens who were sold down the river by their socialist rulers and whoever falsified their financial records and let them into the EU.

    • #7 by Scott Erb on October 20, 2011 - 01:28

      I recall the debate. Greece wasn’t in the first group of states that entered the Eurozone, but lobbied furiously between 1999 and 2001 to be included, claiming they were making progress. I think EU leaders thought the Greek economy was so small that they’d have to conform to the rest of Europe if they were brought in. They were of course already in the EU, which is a good thing, but being in the smaller number of states with the common currency was the mistake. The EU and the Euro will survive this, but hopefully they learned their lesson!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: