Obama Wins Debate I

Last night’s debate between Barack Obama and John McCain has convinced me that this is likely to be a lopsided victory for the Democrat.  Political science theories would all look at conditions and conclude that this is clearly going to be a Democratic victory.  The fact Obama is black, and McCain is running as a maverick might muddy the waters.  But Obama’s debate victory (at least according to early post-debate polling) against John McCain suggests that as long as Obama doesn’t take a major stumble, he will be inaugurated President in January 2009.

First, while on the ‘expectations game’ Obama was expected to do better, the real issue is whether Obama has the stature to be President.  Last night, McCain tried all he could to minimize Obama.  He repeated the mantra “Senator Obama does not understand…” so many times that it became comical.  It was clear he was instructed to say that as often as he could to try to create the impression Obama wasn’t ready.  Yet Obama was clearly in command of his facts and confident; it ended up sounding more condescending than real.

To be sure, there was no knock out punch.  But while McCain sounded themes which will no doubt sound good to partisan Republicans, Obama’s task was not to defeat McCain but to show the country he’s ready to lead.   He had to avoid looking unsteady or unsure.   There are two more debates, but Obama showed tonight — when the topic was foreign policy, supposedly McCain’s strength — that he can handle the pressure.

McCain, in trying to stress his experience, often lingered too much in the past.   That is a risky strategy for him.  The election is about the future, and both candidates claim to be about change.  While it is legitimate for McCain to make the argument he’s been around longer and has dealt with more issues than Obama, stories from the Cold War or the 80s — as well as name dropping — detracts from that notion of focusing on change or the future.

So debate one is over.  McCain headed into it weakened, having tried to “suspend” his campaign to focus on the economic crisis, only to have his efforts seem irrelevant.  Then, despite no deal having been reached, he had to change his mind on his pledge “no deal, no debate” and show up to avoid giving Obama the stage alone.  All this puts Barack a step closer to the Presidency.  There still is time to change the game for McCain, but right now the race seems to be moving towards an Obama victory, perhaps a big one.

  1. #1 by Privatejetter on September 28, 2008 - 01:43

    The first debate between Obama and McCain appeared to be pretty much a draw to me. But since it was supposed to focus on foreign affairs, McCain’s strong suit in terms of experience (although several questions naturally went into the subject of the economy, especially the $700 billion bailout), a tie actually favors Obama. Obama held his own well enough on foreign policy questions, although occasionally put on the defensive by McCain. With this first debate past him, he should have a distinct advantage heading into the last two debates. But only time will tell.


  2. #2 by renaissanceguy on September 28, 2008 - 12:20

    Good analysis.

    Obama looked good, strong, energetic–intelligent even. He is polished and well-prepared. His debate answers, as usual, sound absolutely fantastic! I wish it could work that we could make everyone healthy and happy and it won’t really cost us anything.

    McCain looked seasoned, wise, stately, and noble. He sounded more realistic, because he didn’t promise everything on a silver platter. He doesn’t think that Ahmadinejad is just going to give in after a nice little chat. He doesn’t think that Congress can spend billions of dollars while not raisin taxes. I give him points for factuality.

    Overall winner of the debate: Sad to say, it was probably Obama in most viewers’ minds. For me, it was definitely McCain.

    Probable winner of the election: Obama, I’m afraid.

  3. #3 by languagelover on September 29, 2008 - 04:22

    For me, the turning point of the debate was the point that you mentioned: McCain repeatedly mentioning that “Senator Obama does not understand…” He seemed mean-spirited and bullying with his constant repetition. I would have liked to hear more about what he can do rather than why Obama can’t do it. Throughout the entire debate, Obama came across as thoughtful and polite. McCain seemed cranky and single-minded.

    I’ve tried my hardest to stay open to either candidate, but this debate seemed to exemplify everything I have thought about the candidates. I really can’t see McCain coming out ahead unless Obama really makes a big mistake.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: